FREE HEALTH CHECK
FOR NONPROFITS

Sustainer Program

Is your sustainer program built to grow? This health check looks at how well you make the case for monthly giving with tangible impact, whether the process is easy, and how effectively you invite one-time donors to upgrade.

KEY INSIGHT

71 > 24%

After a year, 71% of sustainers are still active. Only 24% of new online donors give again the next year.

Source: M+R Benchmarks 2026

How this health check works

I’ll assess two parts of your program:

  • Do you make a compelling sustainer case with tangible impact?

  • Could you make that case more powerful and in more places?

  • Are you retargeting key audiences to upgrade?

YOUR KEY MESSAGING

  • Is giving monthly easy?

  • Do one-time donors see a post-gift upgrade lightbox?

  • Is the one-time vs. monthly choice clear?

YOUR DONATION EXPERIENCE

Apply for a
Sustainer Program
health check

Tell me a little about your work and your team.

If I can help, I’ll send you a quick form to gather a few materials for my review.

Connect on LinkedIn

Based in Guilford, Connecticut

© 2026 Blackford Consulting